Home > Business of Medicine > Why Double Coverage is a Scam

Why Double Coverage is a Scam

You have just gotten a job offer that includes health insurance.  You’re lucky enough that your spouse has great family insurance already, but hey that health insurance is going to cover the cracks in the deductible and co-insurance, so you feel great about that double coverage as you sign your contract.n-EMPLOYEE-HEALTH-BENEFITS-628x314

Well, you just got scammed.  That is, double coverage is a scam, and you would have been far better off negotiating a higher salary in return for not getting insurance.

Here’s why:

Let’s say Policy A has a deductible of $1000 and 75% coinsurance up to an out of pocket max of $3000.

Policy B is identical, with a deductible of $1000 and 75% coinsurance up to an out of pocket max of $3000.

So you get $500 in healthcare.   It costs you $500 because neither policy pays up to the first $500 (for simplicity let’s ignore the no-deductible services some policies offer)

Then you have a surgery that costs $5000.    The first policy pays $4000 on this ($5000 minus the $500 deductible that was left, and then 75% of the remaining $2000 on your out of pocket max, plus everything over that).   So that leave’s you with a $1000 bill.  That bill gets submitted to your second policy, which also has a $1000 deductible.   So you still have $500 to satisfy there, and so the second policy pays you $500, or if you’re unlucky in how they interpret the secondary coverage, $375.  So policy 1 pays $4000, and policy 2 pays $375 to $500.

This has always seemed wrong to me.  If you have two life insurance and you die, your family gets paid twice.  But if you have two health insurance policies and you get sick, you only get paid once, or maybe once and a little more.

So if one policy is at more risk than the other, the employer that buys the second policy must pay less for the double coverage policy, right?    No they don’t.  They have to pay full freight for both policies.  That’s where the scam is.

Double coverage is WAY LESS COVERAGE than the single coverage policy, but both policies are priced the same.  This is a product of the fact that large employers are forced to make insurance offerings for their entire population even though that offering may be of substantially less value to some employers than others.

But there is a way to solve this.   Just turn down insurance if you are offered double coverage.  Then tell your prospective employer that by turning down insurance, you are saving them $8 grand a year and ask for $8000 more in salary, or more vacation, or whatever other concession you want.  For them it costs the same, but for you its of dramatically greater value.   When you get that value, squirrel a bit of it away for unpaid healthcare costs.  If you’re lucky and don’t need it, you just have more money.  If you do need the healthcare, you can get the value that would have been paid by the double coverage with a fraction of the money.


Dr. Fogelson is a gynecologic surgeon and endometriosis specialist who practices at Northwest Endometriosis and Pelvic Surgery in Portland, OR.  Call 503-715-1377 for clinical consultation.

Categories: Business of Medicine
  1. Sara P
    September 10, 2018 at 3:32 am

    My husband’s employer routinely sends home letters demanding proof that I am not working in a job that offers health insurance. That is, if the other spouse is working, they refuse to provide health insurance. Double coverage becomes a de facto requirement. I’m curious how often this happens elsewhere.


    • September 10, 2018 at 3:39 am

      I think actually they are doing this so that they _don’t_ provide double coverage.


  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: