Something has got my hackles lately….anonymous medbloggers.
I just don’t get it. If a physician is going to take the time to create a blog to spread his or her opinions and expertise, why wouldn’t they do it under their own name? In a way it really bothers me. There is so much information on the web, and a great deal of it is poorly sourced and unreliable. I would like to think that physicians will publish medical information that is accurate, at least as well as we know, and that the MD or PhD credential will lend credibility to their writings. But to me it just destroys that credibility when the doc chooses to blog under a psuedonym.
I love Seth Godin’s writing. He writes a great deal about how to market things on the internet, and what separates online success from online obscurity. He writes a great article here on the phenomenae of the internet-based expert, something I’ve thought of for a while as well, but have never put into such eloquent words. Though he doesn’t speak directly to medicine here, the relevance is clear.
Somehow the world has gotten the idea that just because there is a lot of information available on the internet they now can become experts overnight. The problem is that all the information in the world does not give someone the clinical judgement of a physician or other experienced practitioner, just as reading a manual on carpentry does not make you an experienced contractor. Reading Harrison‘s does not make you an internist. Reading Gabbe does not make you an obstetrician. It takes years of experience.
The reading is necessary but not sufficient. It takes years of experience and training to get the clinical judgement necessary to use all the facts learned in those books effectively. That is why we supervise residents for 3-8 years before we let them out on the world. Presumably they have already read the books before they start, but clearly they need those years before they really have the skills they need.
Subscribe to Academic OB/GYN Podcast
Support Academic OB/GYN when you Amazon!
- 'Breastfeeding is great for the baby. It's even more important for the mother!' George Saade 20 hours ago
- Breastfeeding reduces mat. obesity and diabetes later in life. Wmn store fat in pregnancy to make milk for baby. So use it to feed baby! 20 hours ago
- RT @BenRittenhouse: I liked a @YouTube video from @academicobgyn youtu.be/t5CelB63QR8?a Delayed Cord Clamping Grand Rounds Part 4 23 hours ago
- Through clap contagion I therefore spread the clap-stop quickly throughout the room.... Saving us all time. 23 hours ago
- When I clap after a talk I always clap exactly 9 times. Enough claps for sincerity, but I end before anyone else. 23 hours ago
- Saw Ender's Game: a good try, but so much less than the book. The book was so deep, far too much to ever be represented in film 2 months ago
- OMG the latest Big Bang Theory is the best. episode. ever. I hate . . . but I had to bust it out for this 2 months ago
- Does anybody have any Vegimals toys? Made in late 1970s by Freemountain toys. I'm buying! 2 months ago
- In ten years if you give a child a 3.5" floppy disk they will say its a 3D printed model of a save icon 2 months ago
- RT @wilw: Stop whatever you’re doing, and go read this right now: jeremycowart.com/2014/01/john-s… 3 months ago
- Academic OB/GYN Answers
- Academic OB/GYN Cases
- Academic OB/GYN Podcast
- ACOG ACM
- Book Reviews
- Business of Medicine
- Cost of Healthcare
- Current Events
- Family Planning
- Fun Stuff
- General OB/GYN Topics
- Green Journal
- Grey Journal
- GYN Oncology
- Infectious Disease
- Journal Articles
- Medical Student Silliness
- Rants and Raves
- Research Methodology
- Resident Mayhem
- Site Administration
- Social Media
- Surgical Videos